Spiersblr
5 months ago
permalink
That’s true, but I fail to see the contradiction. I’m not sure why the two would be mutually exclusive.  The “advertisement” tag up top indicates that it’s an advertisement and not editorial opinion. As does the “sponsored post” label at the bottom, though that particularly term is used less as an identifier for readers (the much more obvious “ADVERTISEMENT” label does that) than for potential media buyers. The phrase exists primarily in media kits to delineate the difference between display and anything involving actual copy in the feature well, the same way real estate inserts in NY Mag, travel inserts in the Times magazine and airline inserts in biz mags all have “ADVERTISEMENT” or “SPONSORED SECTION” printed across the top of the page. It’s the same thing, either way. »

Spiersblr

Yes it is the same thing, and it’s just as awful. It’s just as annoying and intrusive in print as it is online.

The purpose is to make it appear to blend in with the editorial so much that it is barely perceptible to the reader that it isn’t actually copy. I don’t agree with you that everyone notices the “advertisement” in the quarter inch high box above every post, including the editorials. The eyes are not trained to look there, the reader is draw to the headlines. The very idea of putting the ads in that way is to trick the reader, just as it is in print, otherwise it would be a traditional ad.

I’m not even saying there is anything wrong with this, people producing web content are criminally underpaid, but I think we can think of more creative ways to generate money.

Gawker isn’t financially successful because they have great ads, it’s because they know how to generate traffic for their ads.

(via soupsoup)

If I agreed with you that it was barely perceptible, I’d concede the point. But I think it’s only barely perceptible if you’re illiterate—in which you’re not going to read the post anyway.

And you underestimate the extent to which non-display forms of advertising are important re: Gawker’s revenue generation.  Thanks to banner blindness, media buyer boredom with the usual IAB-compliant spots and CPM declines across the board, non-display advertising is more important than it ever has been. And all the traffic in the world doesn’t make one iota of difference business-wise if you can’t properly monetize it (see Post, Huffington.)

Cite Arrow via soupsoup
  1. ninety9 reblogged this from youngmanhattanite and added:
    Again, I was talking about very particularly the form — since advertising is simply ‘the calling attention to’ is it’s...
  2. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from ninety9 and added:
    go down that road even more then NOTHING can be devoid...“hidden” ad or
  3. ninety9 reblogged this from youngmanhattanite and added:
    Depending on whom you poll, some would say YM has ads — they are in service of fund raising, but as dajiner, they spoil...
  4. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from ninety9 and added:
    Hey, that’s my Meet-Up! Also,...think my personal anti-ad stance
  5. ryanbrown reblogged this from spiers
  6. soupsoup reblogged this from spiers and added:
    find any common ground on...they’ve placed...proof that...
  7. ninety9 reblogged this from spiers and added:
    Answering as a dajiner, I provide the following data points: Some people are turned off by practices they deem...
  8. spiers reblogged this from soupsoup
  9. pareene reblogged this from spiers and added:
    That is a very good point. SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION THE PAREENINGTON LAW JOURNAL PRESENTS TUMBLR ATTORNEYS 2009:...
  10. soupsoup reblogged this from spiers and added:
    Spiersblr Yes it is...just as awful. It’s just as annoying
  11. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from spiers and added:
    School is in session, kids.
  12. spiers reblogged this from soupsoup and added:
    That’s true, but...fail to see the contradiction. I’m not sure why the two would be...
  13. andrewgraham reblogged this from soupsoup and added:
    Whatever they are, how can we get Balk or Sheila or someone else to start writing them?
  14. soupsoup posted this
Powered by Tumblr Designed by:Doinwork